When planning a renovation or new build in NYC, you will eventually run into two titles that shape the entire permitting process: the architect and the expediter.
The problem is that many homeowners confuse the two, which leads to stalled approvals, rejected plans, and painful delays. With the Department of Buildings receiving 424 new building permit filings in Q2 2025, a 43% year-over-year increase, the pressure on the permitting system is higher than ever. That surge alone makes it essential to understand who does what before you hire the wrong help.
“Clear roles create clean approvals. Confused roles create expensive detours in every NYC project.” - Menachem Moster, CEO of ACD&E Group.
Let’s break down the real difference between an architect and an expediter, and why choosing correctly will save you stress, time, and money.
What You Actually Hire an Architect to Do
In NYC, an architect is not simply a designer. They are licensed professionals responsible for the safety, legality, and technical accuracy of your building plans. Their stamp is a legal commitment to the work.
According to the New York State Education Department, architects handle everything from consultation and design to construction documents and life-safety and compliance oversight.
Architects complete extensive education, experience, and a national licensing exam before they are allowed to seal drawings.
That means when you are adding a dormer, combining apartments, reconfiguring plumbing, or building anything that touches structure, they are the ones legally responsible for the correctness of the documents.
Permits in NYC must be filed with stamped architectural drawings. Without them, your project cannot even enter the approval queue.
And given that NYC issued over 71 million square feet of new permits in 2024, the importance of accurate architectural documents is higher than ever.
What an Expediter Actually Does
An expediter is not a designer. They are a permitting specialist who manages the bureaucratic pathway your project must move through within the DOB and other agencies. They prepare paperwork, submit filings, monitor review cycles, respond to DOB inquiries, and schedule required appointments.
Think of the architect as the engineer of your building plans and the expediter as the navigator who guides those documents through a very busy, very complex NYC permitting system.
Expediters understand how to get applications reviewed faster. They know which plan examiners respond quickly. They understand how DOB NOW works. They keep filings from getting lost in an approval stack that logged 164,264 work permits during NYC’s 2022 rebound.
But expediters do not design. They do not stamp drawings. They are not liable for errors in the plans. They rely entirely on a licensed architect or engineer to take legal responsibility for the design.
This is the boundary many homeowners misunderstand.
Architect vs Expediter at a Glance
Why NYC Makes the Difference Even More Important
In a smaller town, you might handle permitting yourself. In New York City, that is highly unrealistic. Approvals often take one to three months, even for straightforward projects, and that does not include revisions, objections, or resubmissions.
When the system is overloaded with hundreds of filings per month, mistakes turn into weeks of delay.
New York YIMBY reported that Q3 2024 averaged 357 filings per month, underscoring how competitive the review queue has become.
That is precisely where the architect-expediter partnership becomes essential. One ensures legal accuracy. The other ensures forward momentum.
Your job is to choose the right role at the right moment.
Why You Should Never Treat Architects and Expediters as Interchangeable
When navigating NYC construction, it might be tempting to skip the architect for “simple” projects or rely on an expediter for more than they are legally allowed to do. This is where homeowners and even investors get into trouble.
You might hear someone say, “My expediter will take care of everything.”
But in New York, the law is clear. Only a licensed architect or engineer can design, draft, and stamp drawings.
Expediters cannot offer design services or imply that they can. That separation of responsibilities protects your project and you from fines, stop-work orders, and legal liability.
And with the DOB handling tens of thousands of permits per year, processing over 164,000 work permits in 2022, the system is tightly structured to ensure safety and accuracy.
Understanding that distinction keeps your project legal and moving.
When You Should Rely on Your Architect
Your architect is your design guardian. They translate your vision into a set of documents that comply with zoning regulations, life safety codes, structural requirements, and NYC Energy Code rules. They carry the liability on their seal. They are required to be correct.
Here are situations where you always need your architect to lead:
- Apartment combinations
- Load-bearing wall removals
- Layout changes involving plumbing or gas
- Dormers, extensions, additions, or enlargements
- Legalizing existing noncompliant work
- Any project requiring a new or amended Certificate of Occupancy
If the work touches health, safety, fire separation, or building structure, your architect must take the lead.
And with NYC issuing 71 million square feet of new permits in 2024, building complexity has only increased.
When an Expediter Makes Your Life Easier
An expediter shines when your project enters the bureaucratic maze. They are your guide through DOB NOW, plan examiner questions, sign-offs, and agency-specific processes.
In NYC, expediters reduce friction in situations like:
- Submitting multiple plan revisions
- Meeting DOB requirements for objections
- Coordinating signatures and documentation
- Scheduling inspections or meetings
- Tracking filings for large, multi-site projects
- Maintaining consistent communication with DOB reviewers
This becomes essential when the permitting volume spikes. Q2 of 2025 alone saw 424 new building permit filings, a significant increase from the prior year.
And during peaks like Q3 2024’s 357 monthly filings, your expediter’s familiarity with the system keeps your application from stalling at the bottom of a long review queue.
Who Handles What in NYC Permitting
This table alone helps most homeowners avoid months of miscommunication.
How Choosing Incorrectly Derails Your Project
There is a common story in NYC. A homeowner thinks the job is simple, hires an expediter to “avoid paying architect fees,” and expects smooth sailing.
Then the DOB asks for:
- Revised insulation levels
- Updated window egress calculations
- Structural verification
- Energy code compliance
- Fire separation details
- Updated mechanical diagrams
Only an architect can legally address those items. The expediter cannot modify drawings or certify compliance. That leads to resubmissions, delays, and sometimes total project shutdown.
This is why simple projects often turn complicated. It is not because the work itself is difficult. It is because NYC’s permit requirements are strict, and the wrong professional cannot meet them.
And with permit approvals taking one to three months on average for many NYC projects, every incorrect submission means more waiting.
Where Architects and Expediters Work Best Together
The best outcomes happen when these two roles operate as partners.
The architect designs legally compliant documents.
The expediter shepherds those documents through a busy permitting system.
This collaboration removes ambiguity, eliminates rework, and accelerates approvals. It is the difference between chasing signatures for weeks and getting status updates that tell you exactly where your project stands.
How to Choose Between an Architect and an Expediter in NYC
By now, you can see that both professionals play very different roles. The architect protects safety and design integrity. The expediter protects your timeline by navigating enormous administrative hurdles. Your goal is not to choose one or the other but to choose the right one at the right moment.
And in a city where permit activity continues to surge, with quarterly filings rising 43% year-over-year in 2025, having the right team becomes a strategic advantage rather than a luxury.
So how do you choose the right professional for your situation?
Step-by-Step Guide: Who You Should Hire and When
Below is a simple breakdown that matches common project scenarios with the correct professional to hire.
Use the table like a quick diagnostic tool before you start calling professionals.
Why Pricing Should Not Be Your Primary Decision Factor
Architects and expediters price their services differently. Architects often charge based on the scope of design, whereas expediters may charge line-item fees or full-package pricing. In NYC, where permit applications can take one to three months on average, a lower-cost option that causes delays will ultimately cost more.
Also consider that permit volumes in NYC remain high. For example, Q3 2024 averaged 357 filings per month.
This heavy activity puts pressure on the system. Paying for the wrong help introduces even more pressure.
You are not paying for paperwork.
You are paying to avoid setbacks.
Red Flags to Watch For When Hiring
Be cautious of any professional who:
- Promises approvals without reviewing architectural plans
- Is unwilling to disclose whether they outsource tasks
- Suggests they can handle design tasks without a license
- Encourages shortcuts that violate code compliance
- Cannot clearly explain the DOB process in your borough
- Tells you a stamp is “just a formality”
Architects and expediters must stay in their lane. That separation protects you.
FAQ: Architect vs Expediter in NYC
Do I always need both an architect and an expediter?
Not always. Small interior updates may only require an architect. Large or time-sensitive projects benefit from having both.
Can an expediter create or stamp drawings?
No. Only licensed architects or engineers can design and stamp drawings in NYC. Expediters focus on filings and communication.
Why do some people try using only an expediter?
They often think the project is simpler than it is. But when the DOB asks for code documentation or structural justification, only an architect can legally respond.
Do architects handle permitting themselves?
Sometimes. Some firms do in-house filing. Others prefer working with dedicated expediters because the workload is heavy, primarily when NYC handles over 164,000 work permits in a year.
Who should I hire first?
Start with an architect. They define what you are legally building. Once plans are ready, the expediter moves the paperwork through DOB.
Final thoughts
Architects design the blueprint of your space. Expediters guide that blueprint through one of the busiest permitting systems in the country. When both roles work together, you get a project that is compliant, buildable, and approved without unnecessary delay.
Choosing the right partner from the start is the simplest way to prevent detours, reversals, and headaches later. If you want a team that manages design accuracy and permitting efficiency with the same level of precision, ACD&E Group is here to help you move forward with clarity and confidence.
.png)
.png)